Welcome to the staging ground for new communities! Each proposal has a description in the "Descriptions" category and a body of questions and answers in "Incubator Q&A". You can ask questions (and get answers, we hope!) right away, and start new proposals.
Are you here to participate in a specific proposal? Click on the proposal tag (with the dark outline) to see only posts about that proposal and not all of the others that are in progress. Tags are at the bottom of each post.
Comments on Scope discussion for Sports
Parent
Scope discussion for Sports
I have updated and formalized the scope definition of the Sports proposal. This post is intended as a general discussion post regarding site scope.
Specifically as of 24-06-27, I would like feedback regarding if these things should be on-topic? I added them but have no strong opinions about any of it myself.
- Motor sports
- Animal sports
- E-sports
- Sports history
- Statistics
- Sports equipment recommendations
Post
I'm OK with all of your points except equipment recommendations and possibly E-sports.
Equipment recommendations
Shopping questions or "which model should I get" are a bad fit for this kind of site. The reasons have been elaborated at length Elsewhere, and also here occasionally.
There are some gray areas that I could see allowing. If the question is more about the type of device versus which model, it could be on topic. For example, "Are there any drawbacks to velcro-tie shoes versus traditional shoelace-tie for running? What about sports where pivoting and changing direction are important, like soccer?" would be on topic, whereas "Which velcro-tie shoe is best for jogging?" would be off topic.
E-sport
I don't know what an E-sport is, so can't say whether it should be on topic. The name suggests something done on a computer, which isn't a "sport" as I think of it.
The difference between a "sport" and a "game" is that the former has a component of physical or athletic actions central to the competition. Clicking a mouse, even with the right timing, isn't the kind of physical actions I mean. For example, soccer is clearly a sport since running, kicking a ball, and other obvious athletic actions are integral to it. Chess is a game. You compete by thinking. The ability to pick up pieces and move them around isn't sufficiently athletic, and the game doesn't really hinge on your physical ability to do that well.
3 comment threads
0 comment threads