Welcome to the staging ground for new communities! Each proposal has a description in the "Descriptions" category and a body of questions and answers in "Incubator Q&A". You can ask questions (and get answers, we hope!) right away, and start new proposals.
Are you here to participate in a specific proposal? Click on the proposal tag (with the dark outline) to see only posts about that proposal and not all of the others that are in progress. Tags are at the bottom of each post.
Post History
Site Name Everyday Science Description For interdisciplinary questions about the world around us, examining reality from an XKCD perspective. Topics Topics covered would include: Lay scie...
Wiki
everyday-science
#4: Post edited
by
Karl Knechtel
·
2023-09-21T19:51:42Z (about 1 year ago)
Everyday STEM
- Everyday Science
- ### Site Name
Everyday STEM- ### Description
- For interdisciplinary questions about the world around us, examining reality from an XKCD perspective.
- ### Topics
- Topics covered would include:
- - Lay science questions about common household objects (e.g. ["Why is icing sugar less dense than granulated sugar?"](https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/123711), or "why can cheese both harden and soften when left out?") or easily observed aspects of the natural world ("Why is the sky blue?"), especially if they are seemingly simple ideas that need an interdisciplinary examination to answer in detail
- - The inner workings of household appliances and gadgets and commonly-encountered objects like street lights (i.e., the sort of things examined [on this Youtube channel](https://www.youtube.com/@TechnologyConnections))
- - Designs for simple DIY devices, furniture etc., and the engineering considerations involved (e.g. why diagonal bracing improves the strength of furniture and how to incorporate it in a design, or what materials/thicknesses are required to support a safe load)
- - Applied mathematics around the home, e.g. "home economics" questions like "how cheap does X have to be before I should consider substituting it for Y in my recipe?"
- ### Exclusions
- These topics or types of posts would be out of scope:
- - Questions with a legal or political aspect, even if they have a practical consequence (e.g. "what driving speeds are 'safe'?", "why is the tax code so complex?")
- - Questions related to the operation of a business
- - Questions about devices that are neither commonly used around a modern household, nor interacted with on a daily basis either by urbanites (city infrastructure) or rural dwellers (farm equipment)
- - Questions purely about budgeting, that don't relate to the specific nature of a specific good or service being budgeted *for* (such questions should go to Accounting, Finance or Mathematics)
- - Localized or regional questions that don't require calculation or scientific knowledge to answer (e.g. "Which grocery chain offers the best price on X?"; but e.g. calculating unit prices and factoring in transportation costs for a hypothetical situation would be on topic, and "should I have groceries delivered or pick them up myself?" should work as well)
- - Speculative or theoretical questions belong on Scientific Speculation instead; this site would be for understanding actually observed phenomena and solving practical problems related thereto.
- ### Special Features
- Probably none.
- ### Overlaps
- Overlap with Physics, Cooking, Mathematics and Electrical Engineering all seem possible. Cooking and food-oriented questions in the new site should be focused on the science behind cooking rather than on actually working out recipes and such; similarly, the technical questions should have an explicit layperson orientation. The idea is to sit at the existing intersection of these sites and have a place to marvel at the subtle complexity of the world around us.
- Some overlap may also be possible with the new Home Improvement proposal.
- ### Site Name
- Everyday Science
- ### Description
- For interdisciplinary questions about the world around us, examining reality from an XKCD perspective.
- ### Topics
- Topics covered would include:
- - Lay science questions about common household objects (e.g. ["Why is icing sugar less dense than granulated sugar?"](https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/123711), or "why can cheese both harden and soften when left out?") or easily observed aspects of the natural world ("Why is the sky blue?"), especially if they are seemingly simple ideas that need an interdisciplinary examination to answer in detail
- - The inner workings of household appliances and gadgets and commonly-encountered objects like street lights (i.e., the sort of things examined [on this Youtube channel](https://www.youtube.com/@TechnologyConnections))
- - Designs for simple DIY devices, furniture etc., and the engineering considerations involved (e.g. why diagonal bracing improves the strength of furniture and how to incorporate it in a design, or what materials/thicknesses are required to support a safe load)
- - Applied mathematics around the home, e.g. "home economics" questions like "how cheap does X have to be before I should consider substituting it for Y in my recipe?"
- ### Exclusions
- These topics or types of posts would be out of scope:
- - Questions with a legal or political aspect, even if they have a practical consequence (e.g. "what driving speeds are 'safe'?", "why is the tax code so complex?")
- - Questions related to the operation of a business
- - Questions about devices that are neither commonly used around a modern household, nor interacted with on a daily basis either by urbanites (city infrastructure) or rural dwellers (farm equipment)
- - Questions purely about budgeting, that don't relate to the specific nature of a specific good or service being budgeted *for* (such questions should go to Accounting, Finance or Mathematics)
- - Localized or regional questions that don't require calculation or scientific knowledge to answer (e.g. "Which grocery chain offers the best price on X?"; but e.g. calculating unit prices and factoring in transportation costs for a hypothetical situation would be on topic, and "should I have groceries delivered or pick them up myself?" should work as well)
- - Speculative or theoretical questions belong on Scientific Speculation instead; this site would be for understanding actually observed phenomena and solving practical problems related thereto.
- ### Special Features
- Probably none.
- ### Overlaps
- Overlap with Physics, Cooking, Mathematics and Electrical Engineering all seem possible. Cooking and food-oriented questions in the new site should be focused on the science behind cooking rather than on actually working out recipes and such; similarly, the technical questions should have an explicit layperson orientation. The idea is to sit at the existing intersection of these sites and have a place to marvel at the subtle complexity of the world around us.
- Some overlap may also be possible with the new Home Improvement proposal.
#3: Post edited
by
Karl Knechtel
·
2023-09-18T03:14:03Z (about 1 year ago)
Rename per comment discussion
Domestic STEM
- Everyday STEM
- ### Site Name
Domestic STEM- ### Description
- For interdisciplinary questions about the world around us, examining reality from an XKCD perspective.
- ### Topics
- Topics covered would include:
- - Lay science questions about common household objects (e.g. ["Why is icing sugar less dense than granulated sugar?"](https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/123711), or "why can cheese both harden and soften when left out?") or easily observed aspects of the natural world ("Why is the sky blue?"), especially if they are seemingly simple ideas that need an interdisciplinary examination to answer in detail
- - The inner workings of household appliances and gadgets and commonly-encountered objects like street lights (i.e., the sort of things examined [on this Youtube channel](https://www.youtube.com/@TechnologyConnections))
- - Designs for simple DIY devices, furniture etc., and the engineering considerations involved (e.g. why diagonal bracing improves the strength of furniture and how to incorporate it in a design, or what materials/thicknesses are required to support a safe load)
- - Applied mathematics around the home, e.g. "home economics" questions like "how cheap does X have to be before I should consider substituting it for Y in my recipe?"
- ### Exclusions
- These topics or types of posts would be out of scope:
- - Questions with a legal or political aspect, even if they have a practical consequence (e.g. "what driving speeds are 'safe'?", "why is the tax code so complex?")
- - Questions related to the operation of a business
- - Questions about devices that are neither commonly used around a modern household, nor interacted with on a daily basis either by urbanites (city infrastructure) or rural dwellers (farm equipment)
- - Questions purely about budgeting, that don't relate to the specific nature of a specific good or service being budgeted *for* (such questions should go to Accounting, Finance or Mathematics)
- - Localized or regional questions that don't require calculation or scientific knowledge to answer (e.g. "Which grocery chain offers the best price on X?"; but e.g. calculating unit prices and factoring in transportation costs for a hypothetical situation would be on topic, and "should I have groceries delivered or pick them up myself?" should work as well)
- - Speculative or theoretical questions belong on Scientific Speculation instead; this site would be for understanding actually observed phenomena and solving practical problems related thereto.
- ### Special Features
- Probably none.
- ### Overlaps
- Overlap with Physics, Cooking, Mathematics and Electrical Engineering all seem possible. Cooking and food-oriented questions in the new site should be focused on the science behind cooking rather than on actually working out recipes and such; similarly, the technical questions should have an explicit layperson orientation. The idea is to sit at the existing intersection of these sites and have a place to marvel at the subtle complexity of the world around us.
- Some overlap may also be possible with the new Home Improvement proposal.
- ### Site Name
- Everyday STEM
- ### Description
- For interdisciplinary questions about the world around us, examining reality from an XKCD perspective.
- ### Topics
- Topics covered would include:
- - Lay science questions about common household objects (e.g. ["Why is icing sugar less dense than granulated sugar?"](https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/123711), or "why can cheese both harden and soften when left out?") or easily observed aspects of the natural world ("Why is the sky blue?"), especially if they are seemingly simple ideas that need an interdisciplinary examination to answer in detail
- - The inner workings of household appliances and gadgets and commonly-encountered objects like street lights (i.e., the sort of things examined [on this Youtube channel](https://www.youtube.com/@TechnologyConnections))
- - Designs for simple DIY devices, furniture etc., and the engineering considerations involved (e.g. why diagonal bracing improves the strength of furniture and how to incorporate it in a design, or what materials/thicknesses are required to support a safe load)
- - Applied mathematics around the home, e.g. "home economics" questions like "how cheap does X have to be before I should consider substituting it for Y in my recipe?"
- ### Exclusions
- These topics or types of posts would be out of scope:
- - Questions with a legal or political aspect, even if they have a practical consequence (e.g. "what driving speeds are 'safe'?", "why is the tax code so complex?")
- - Questions related to the operation of a business
- - Questions about devices that are neither commonly used around a modern household, nor interacted with on a daily basis either by urbanites (city infrastructure) or rural dwellers (farm equipment)
- - Questions purely about budgeting, that don't relate to the specific nature of a specific good or service being budgeted *for* (such questions should go to Accounting, Finance or Mathematics)
- - Localized or regional questions that don't require calculation or scientific knowledge to answer (e.g. "Which grocery chain offers the best price on X?"; but e.g. calculating unit prices and factoring in transportation costs for a hypothetical situation would be on topic, and "should I have groceries delivered or pick them up myself?" should work as well)
- - Speculative or theoretical questions belong on Scientific Speculation instead; this site would be for understanding actually observed phenomena and solving practical problems related thereto.
- ### Special Features
- Probably none.
- ### Overlaps
- Overlap with Physics, Cooking, Mathematics and Electrical Engineering all seem possible. Cooking and food-oriented questions in the new site should be focused on the science behind cooking rather than on actually working out recipes and such; similarly, the technical questions should have an explicit layperson orientation. The idea is to sit at the existing intersection of these sites and have a place to marvel at the subtle complexity of the world around us.
- Some overlap may also be possible with the new Home Improvement proposal.
#2: Post edited
by
Karl Knechtel
·
2023-09-14T20:57:49Z (about 1 year ago)
- ### Site Name
- Domestic STEM
- ### Description
- For interdisciplinary questions about the world around us, examining reality from an XKCD perspective.
- ### Topics
- Topics covered would include:
- - Lay science questions about common household objects (e.g. ["Why is icing sugar less dense than granulated sugar?"](https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/123711), or "why can cheese both harden and soften when left out?") or easily observed aspects of the natural world ("Why is the sky blue?"), especially if they are seemingly simple ideas that need an interdisciplinary examination to answer in detail
- - The inner workings of household appliances and gadgets and commonly-encountered objects like street lights (i.e., the sort of things examined [on this Youtube channel](https://www.youtube.com/@TechnologyConnections))
- - Designs for simple DIY devices, furniture etc., and the engineering considerations involved (e.g. why diagonal bracing improves the strength of furniture and how to incorporate it in a design, or what materials/thicknesses are required to support a safe load)
- - Applied mathematics around the home, e.g. "home economics" questions like "how cheap does X have to be before I should consider substituting it for Y in my recipe?"
- ### Exclusions
- These topics or types of posts would be out of scope:
- - Questions with a legal or political aspect, even if they have a practical consequence (e.g. "what driving speeds are 'safe'?", "why is the tax code so complex?")
- - Questions related to the operation of a business
- - Questions about devices that are neither commonly used around a modern household, nor interacted with on a daily basis either by urbanites (city infrastructure) or rural dwellers (farm equipment)
- - Questions purely about budgeting, that don't relate to the specific nature of a specific good or service being budgeted *for* (such questions should go to Accounting, Finance or Mathematics)
- - Localized or regional questions that don't require calculation or scientific knowledge to answer (e.g. "Which grocery chain offers the best price on X?"; but e.g. calculating unit prices and factoring in transportation costs for a hypothetical situation would be on topic, and "should I have groceries delivered or pick them up myself?" should work as well)
- ### Special Features
- Probably none.
- ### Overlaps
- Overlap with Physics, Cooking, Mathematics and Electrical Engineering all seem possible. Cooking and food-oriented questions in the new site should be focused on the science behind cooking rather than on actually working out recipes and such; similarly, the technical questions should have an explicit layperson orientation. The idea is to sit at the existing intersection of these sites and have a place to marvel at the subtle complexity of the world around us.
- Some overlap may also be possible with the new Home Improvement proposal.
- ### Site Name
- Domestic STEM
- ### Description
- For interdisciplinary questions about the world around us, examining reality from an XKCD perspective.
- ### Topics
- Topics covered would include:
- - Lay science questions about common household objects (e.g. ["Why is icing sugar less dense than granulated sugar?"](https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/123711), or "why can cheese both harden and soften when left out?") or easily observed aspects of the natural world ("Why is the sky blue?"), especially if they are seemingly simple ideas that need an interdisciplinary examination to answer in detail
- - The inner workings of household appliances and gadgets and commonly-encountered objects like street lights (i.e., the sort of things examined [on this Youtube channel](https://www.youtube.com/@TechnologyConnections))
- - Designs for simple DIY devices, furniture etc., and the engineering considerations involved (e.g. why diagonal bracing improves the strength of furniture and how to incorporate it in a design, or what materials/thicknesses are required to support a safe load)
- - Applied mathematics around the home, e.g. "home economics" questions like "how cheap does X have to be before I should consider substituting it for Y in my recipe?"
- ### Exclusions
- These topics or types of posts would be out of scope:
- - Questions with a legal or political aspect, even if they have a practical consequence (e.g. "what driving speeds are 'safe'?", "why is the tax code so complex?")
- - Questions related to the operation of a business
- - Questions about devices that are neither commonly used around a modern household, nor interacted with on a daily basis either by urbanites (city infrastructure) or rural dwellers (farm equipment)
- - Questions purely about budgeting, that don't relate to the specific nature of a specific good or service being budgeted *for* (such questions should go to Accounting, Finance or Mathematics)
- - Localized or regional questions that don't require calculation or scientific knowledge to answer (e.g. "Which grocery chain offers the best price on X?"; but e.g. calculating unit prices and factoring in transportation costs for a hypothetical situation would be on topic, and "should I have groceries delivered or pick them up myself?" should work as well)
- - Speculative or theoretical questions belong on Scientific Speculation instead; this site would be for understanding actually observed phenomena and solving practical problems related thereto.
- ### Special Features
- Probably none.
- ### Overlaps
- Overlap with Physics, Cooking, Mathematics and Electrical Engineering all seem possible. Cooking and food-oriented questions in the new site should be focused on the science behind cooking rather than on actually working out recipes and such; similarly, the technical questions should have an explicit layperson orientation. The idea is to sit at the existing intersection of these sites and have a place to marvel at the subtle complexity of the world around us.
- Some overlap may also be possible with the new Home Improvement proposal.
#1: Initial revision
by
Karl Knechtel
·
2023-09-14T20:55:17Z (about 1 year ago)
Domestic STEM
### Site Name
Domestic STEM
### Description
For interdisciplinary questions about the world around us, examining reality from an XKCD perspective.
### Topics
Topics covered would include:
- Lay science questions about common household objects (e.g. ["Why is icing sugar less dense than granulated sugar?"](https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/123711), or "why can cheese both harden and soften when left out?") or easily observed aspects of the natural world ("Why is the sky blue?"), especially if they are seemingly simple ideas that need an interdisciplinary examination to answer in detail
- The inner workings of household appliances and gadgets and commonly-encountered objects like street lights (i.e., the sort of things examined [on this Youtube channel](https://www.youtube.com/@TechnologyConnections))
- Designs for simple DIY devices, furniture etc., and the engineering considerations involved (e.g. why diagonal bracing improves the strength of furniture and how to incorporate it in a design, or what materials/thicknesses are required to support a safe load)
- Applied mathematics around the home, e.g. "home economics" questions like "how cheap does X have to be before I should consider substituting it for Y in my recipe?"
### Exclusions
These topics or types of posts would be out of scope:
- Questions with a legal or political aspect, even if they have a practical consequence (e.g. "what driving speeds are 'safe'?", "why is the tax code so complex?")
- Questions related to the operation of a business
- Questions about devices that are neither commonly used around a modern household, nor interacted with on a daily basis either by urbanites (city infrastructure) or rural dwellers (farm equipment)
- Questions purely about budgeting, that don't relate to the specific nature of a specific good or service being budgeted *for* (such questions should go to Accounting, Finance or Mathematics)
- Localized or regional questions that don't require calculation or scientific knowledge to answer (e.g. "Which grocery chain offers the best price on X?"; but e.g. calculating unit prices and factoring in transportation costs for a hypothetical situation would be on topic, and "should I have groceries delivered or pick them up myself?" should work as well)
### Special Features
Probably none.
### Overlaps
Overlap with Physics, Cooking, Mathematics and Electrical Engineering all seem possible. Cooking and food-oriented questions in the new site should be focused on the science behind cooking rather than on actually working out recipes and such; similarly, the technical questions should have an explicit layperson orientation. The idea is to sit at the existing intersection of these sites and have a place to marvel at the subtle complexity of the world around us.
Some overlap may also be possible with the new Home Improvement proposal.