Welcome to the staging ground for new communities! Each proposal has a description in the "Descriptions" category and a body of questions and answers in "Incubator Q&A". You can ask questions (and get answers, we hope!) right away, and start new proposals.
Are you here to participate in a specific proposal? Click on the proposal tag (with the dark outline) to see only posts about that proposal and not all of the others that are in progress. Tags are at the bottom of each post.
Post History
There is a fundamental flaw: The proposals are not read by everyone. And also new users will not find them first thing and also do not know that the "react" function exists. As you might have notic...
Answer
#2: Post edited
by
Antares
·
2024-09-06T22:32:21Z (3 months ago)
- There is a fundamental flaw: The proposals are not read by everyone. And also new users will not find them first thing and also do not know that the "react" function exists. As you might have noticed, not even the proposal poster has reacted on his own proposal ;)
- I also do not want to know who will be a participant in the community-to-be. I really would like to know if people here are "against" such a community. And I am going to ask "why" if the downvotes keep pouring in (if I still care at that point).
- Because I can guarantee you: If this community-to-be is not endorsed here, I will not waste my time in trying to establish it here.
- I really cannot imagine why a larger community of Q&A sites (I mean all of Codidact here) need to express their disapproval towards something "new".
- While at the same time not appreciating that there is something being in the making.
- I for one would upvote any and all posts regarding a new community, wether I am interested in it or not. Just to send the signal: "Go ahead. I won't stop you. If you can do it, I'm glad to have you here".
As it stands now (+0/-3) well, you can imagine which signal this sends.
- There is a fundamental flaw: The proposals are not read by everyone. And also new users will not find them first thing and also do not know that the "react" function exists. As you might have noticed, not even the proposal poster has reacted on his own proposal ;)
- I also do not want to know who will be a participant in the community-to-be. I really would like to know if people here are "against" such a community. And I am going to ask "why" if the downvotes keep pouring in (if I still care at that point).
- Because I can guarantee you: If this community-to-be is not endorsed here, I will not waste my time in trying to establish it here.
- I really cannot imagine why a larger community of Q&A sites (I mean all of Codidact here) need to express their disapproval towards something "new".
- While at the same time not appreciating that there is something being in the making.
- I for one would upvote any and all posts regarding a new community, wether I am interested in it or not. Just to send the signal: "Go ahead. I won't stop you. If you can do it, I'm glad to have you here".
- As it stands now (+0/-3) well, you can imagine which signal this sends.
- **On a sidenote:** I think it is rude implying I would not know about the react function, if you can see that I have "registered" there.
- I was not asking "How can I express my interest". I was asking "Who is PRO Worldbuilding here".
- My intent is crystall-clear I think - If not, please give me feedback on this.
#1: Initial revision
by
Antares
·
2024-09-06T22:27:41Z (3 months ago)
There is a fundamental flaw: The proposals are not read by everyone. And also new users will not find them first thing and also do not know that the "react" function exists. As you might have noticed, not even the proposal poster has reacted on his own proposal ;) I also do not want to know who will be a participant in the community-to-be. I really would like to know if people here are "against" such a community. And I am going to ask "why" if the downvotes keep pouring in (if I still care at that point). Because I can guarantee you: If this community-to-be is not endorsed here, I will not waste my time in trying to establish it here. I really cannot imagine why a larger community of Q&A sites (I mean all of Codidact here) need to express their disapproval towards something "new". While at the same time not appreciating that there is something being in the making. I for one would upvote any and all posts regarding a new community, wether I am interested in it or not. Just to send the signal: "Go ahead. I won't stop you. If you can do it, I'm glad to have you here". As it stands now (+0/-3) well, you can imagine which signal this sends.