Welcome to the staging ground for new communities! Each proposal has a description in the "Descriptions" category and a body of questions and answers in "Incubator Q&A". You can ask questions (and get answers, we hope!) right away, and start new proposals.
Why can't the body clear / drain a periapical tooth abscess on its own? [closed] Question
Closed as community not specified by Monica Cellio on Nov 19, 2023 at 21:43
This question is missing a tag for an active community proposal. If the proposal this question is part of exists, please add the tag and the question can be reopened. If the proposal does not yet exist, please start an entry in the Descriptions category to describe the intended community. Descriptions can be fleshed out over time.
This question was closed; new answers can no longer be added. Users with the reopen privilege may vote to reopen this question if it has been improved or closed incorrectly.
Every single article I've read about periapical tooth abscess (including the one on this previous link) states that it won't go away without treatment.
I mean it's just hard for me to understand how, according to the current medical consensus, even a fully healthy human body, well-equipped with fighting infections can still succumb to an internal abscess without surgical intervention.
Please explain and/or cite a medical paper, book, etc. that goes into the details why these abscesses cannot be cleared on their own.
1 answer
I can't provide a specific answer, but I'll try a general one based on evolutionary theory and (refuted) teleology.
The body is indeed equipped to fight infections. I believe the human immune system is particularly strong, compared to other animals.
However, it is incorrect to think of "immunity" to infections. There is an ongoing arms race between infectious agents and hosts where one evolves defenses and the other evolves countermeasures. At any given point in evolutionary history, it is not unexpected to find that certain microorganisms are able to overcome defenses of their chosen host and cause problems. This defeats one premise in the question, that of surprise at a healthy body not being able to drain the abscess.
Moreover, not all potential evolutionary improvements are instantly realized. Evolution happens in steps of a generation, which for humans is a few decades. Many changes require multiple steps. If the selective pressure is weak, it can take even longer. Considering that humans arose on the order of 1 million years ago, that's 10-100k generations, not really a huge amount of space to optimize things. We are very much a "WIP" species, many bugs and serious breakage should be expected. Of course, evolution was acting for much longer on our primate and therapsid ancestors, but then non-human tooth diseases are a whole other can of worms.
Lastly, tooth diseases have greatly changed in modern industrial society. The modern diet, which came to be in the last few centuries, is vastly different from what our ancestors experienced for 99% of our evolutionary history. Refined sugar, for example, was not readily available until a few centuries ago, and life histories of humans were much different prior to the advent of modern healthcare and nutrition. Thus, perhaps we should not expect thousands of rounds of selection but merely tens or hundreds in the case of dental disease.
This doesn't really answer the question, but I think it's a sufficient argument for why we shouldn't be surprised that nature has endowed us with bodies which cannot drain tooth abscesses. Aside from the answer of should the abscesses drain on their own, there is still the question of what prevents them from draining, anatomically speaking. My answer is already long so I will leave the anatomy to a different answer.
0 comment threads
4 comment threads